金球獎(Golden Globe) 2005 Best Performance by an Actor in a Mini-Series or a Motion Picture Made for Television (提名) 茅斯·達夫 Best Mini-Series or Motion Picture Made for Television (提名) 金衛星獎(Golden Satellite Award) 2005 Best Motion Picture Made for Television (提名) 金衛星獎 2005 Best Actor in a Miniseries or a Motion Picture Made for Television (提名) 茅斯·達夫 Best Actress in a Supporting Role in a Series, Mini-Series or Motion Picture Made for Television (提名) 瑪麗·斯圖爾特·馬斯特森 Best Actor in a Miniseries or a Motion Picture Made for Television (提名) 艾倫·瑞克曼 艾美獎(Emmy) 2004 Outstanding Made for Television Movie Mike Drake Outstanding Made for Television Movie Robert W. Cort Outstanding Made for Television Movie Eric Hetzel Outstanding Single-Camera Picture Editing for a Miniseries, Movie or a Special Michael Brown Outstanding Made for Television Movie Julian Krainin Outstanding Single-Camera Sound Mixing for a Miniseries or a Movie (提名) Bruce Litecky Outstanding Casting for a Miniseries, Movie or a Special (提名) Lynn Kressel Outstanding Casting for a Miniseries, Movie or a Special (提名) Pat Moran Outstanding Directing for a Miniseries, Movie or a Dramatic Special (提名) 約瑟夫·薩金特 Outstanding Single-Camera Sound Mixing for a Miniseries or a Movie (提名) Rick Ash Outstanding Single-Camera Sound Mixing for a Miniseries or a Movie (提名) Adam Jenkins 艾美獎 2004 Outstanding Made for Television Movie David Madden Outstanding Cinematography for a Miniseries or Movie Donald M. Morgan Outstanding Lead Actor in a Miniseries or a Movie (提名) 艾倫·瑞克曼 Outstanding Lead Actor in a Miniseries or a Movie (提名) 茅斯·達夫 廣播影評人協會獎(Critics Choice Award) 2005 Best Picture Made for Television (提名) Television Critics Association Awards(TCA Award) 2005 Outstanding Achievement Movies, Mini-Series and Specials (提名) Peabody Awards(Peabody Award) 2005 PGA Awards(Television Producer of the Year Award in Longform) 2005 unknown (提名) NAMIC Vision Awards(Vision Award) 2005 Drama NAMIC Vision Awards 2005 Best Dramatic Performance 茅斯·達夫 Image Awards(Image Award) 2005 Outstanding Television Movie, Mini-Series or Dramatic Special Outstanding Actor in a Television Movie, Mini-Series or Dramatic Special (提名) 茅斯·達夫 Outstanding Actress in a Television Movie, Mini-Series or Dramatic Special (提名) 加布里埃爾·尤尼恩 Directors Guild of America, USA(DGA Award) 2005 Outstanding Directorial Achievement in Movies for Television Joe Incaprera Outstanding Directorial Achievement in Movies for Television Karyn McCarthy Outstanding Directorial Achievement in Movies for Television Michele Ziegler Directors Guild of America, USA 2005 Outstanding Directorial Achievement in Movies for Television Xanthus Valan Outstanding Directorial Achievement in Movies for Television 約瑟夫·薩金特 Cinema Audio Society, USA(C.A.S. Award) 2005 Outstanding Achievement in Sound Mixing for Television - Movies and Mini-Series (提名) Adam Jenkins Outstanding Achievement in Sound Mixing for Television - Movies and Mini-Series (提名) Rick Ash Outstanding Achievement in Sound Mixing for Television - Movies and Mini-Series (提名) Bruce Litecky Casting Society of America, USA(Artios) 2004 Best Casting for TV Movie of the Week Lynn Kressel Best Casting for TV Movie of the Week Pat Moran Black Reel Awards(Black Reel) 2005 Best Supporting Actor, Network/Cable Television Clayton LeBouef ( Best Supporting Actress, Network/Cable Television (提名) 加布里埃爾·尤尼恩 Best Director, Network/Cable Television (提名) 約瑟夫·薩金特 Best Actor, Network/Cable Television (提名) 茅斯·達夫 American Cinema Editors, USA(Eddie) 2005 Best Edited Miniseries or Motion Picture for Non-Commercial Television Michael Brown
在幾十年的跨度中，Vivien的人生一直內蘊、緊張但始終沒有爆發。小時候因為手太穩、手藝太好而下崗，進而機緣湊巧地成為了Dr. Alfred 的實驗室助手。這是他命中注定的位置。黑人與白人不得同時入內，這是戲劇張力之一。工作助手與生死朋友有別，這是戲劇張力之二。職業理想與現實差距，這是戲劇張力之三。很多的不得已而為之，令人唏噓。所有的張力到了最後，Vivien 被授予榮譽博士時，才最終得到了釋放。我看這部片子時總想起《湯姆叔叔的小屋》，那種載道以遠的謙卑人生才可以給予觀者無窮大的震撼力。
Vivien 的表演者把握得很到位，雖然低眉順從，但那一點受到生活煎熬和不公正待遇的憤懣之情總會從眉宇之間流露出來。他在最後的老者扮相比實際的畫像也有神似之處。那篇發言稿更多的是感恩之情。上蒼待己不薄，那些受過的苦楚又何足道哉？這便是信仰的好處了。
Dr. Alfred 的扮演者是 Alan，嗯，看的時候總有點斯內普教授的影子哈，尤其是口音。典型的天才，傲慢而偏執。他不是對人傲慢，而是對學術傲慢，他覺得自己可以戰勝上帝製造的錯誤。不得不說，進步確實是偏執狂才能造就出來的。Alan 在這方面的表演很好。Dr. Alfred 比 Vivien 等而下之的地方在於，前者更多關心的學術上的樹碑立傳、發前人之所未發以及逆天行事，他對於醫術/生命的虔誠遠遠比不上後者對於生活的虔誠。也可以說，他的白人身份讓他缺少了 Vivien 那種悲劇感，因此他所取得成就的震撼力也就比不上後者年屆古稀方得道的震撼了。
